Hello Everyone!
I hope you are staying
warm during this fall, however it feels more like winter. This semester has
been a hard one, but I am staying afloat. No matter what though, I am always
looking forward to teaching. It is my breath of fresh air, and getting to be with
my students and work with them has been a delight for me this semester. I have
truly been blessed with a great class that follows the rules and never speaks
out of turn. They are open to trying new things, so I have gotten the
opportunity to try some new stuff, and see what sort of things I want to use and
don’t want to use in my classroom. There is this one student that I am having
trouble with. She shows up late every day and just sits and texts or sleeps the
entire class. Whenever I call on her for an answer she just says “Yeah right”
and then goes back to texting. At my placement, the school policy states I
cannot take the phone away from her, and that I can only take points away.
I have been trying to
reach her, but she keeps fighting me. At the beginning of the semester she was
one of my best students, but now she is distant and cold. I’m guessing it has
to do something with her home life, but I cannot be for certain. Like I said I
have been able to experiment more with this class, so this semester I have been
trying to use conversations and discussions to help bring this student back
into the class. According to Bomer “We live in an age where work gets done
through collaboration.” (Bomer 135) This statement is absolutely correct. In
today’s society, we have never been more connected. We must collaborate if we
want to survive in the modern world. Right now I’m collaborating with you
reading this post!
I read what Bomer had to
say on trying to get the students to respond. One of the ideas that he presents
really caught my eye. “Pull on the differences to draw them out. Good conversation
usually involves negotiating things that members of the group see differently.”
(Bomer 139) I used this idea to my advantage with this student of mine. We were
having a debate on whether or not alcohol should be banned like it was during prohibition.
(We are reading on the Harlem Renaissance) She is one of those students who is
very opinionated, especially when it comes to alcohol as I’m assuming she is
fan because she has worn a Jack Daniels hoody to class several times. She got
really into the debate, and she was way against prohibition, and got into a
great debate with several of my students who were siding with the logic of
prohibition.
Now Bomer’s text isn’t
meant to help with problem students. It’s supposed to help me be a better
teacher. So my question is, what are some ways you guys would deal with this
student? How would you get her to get off her phone and pay attention? Remember
I can’t take her phone. I can only take her participation points for the day,
and she isn’t breaking any classroom rules. Thanks in advance for your input,
and I hope you all are having a blessed year!
Till next time, have a
great Thanksgiving, and a wonderful holiday season everyone!
Mr. Mann
Thanks for your post, Austin. A couple of suggestions come to mind regarding your question. These were my go-to strategies when I was teaching middle school ...
ReplyDelete1. Conference with the student outside of class. Ask the student if there are things you could do differently in the class to make it more engaging for her. Let her know that using her phone while you are teaching, while others are speaking, etc. is discourteous. Encourage her to demonstrate respect/courteous use of electronic devices when she is in your classroom. Explain how her continued use of the device is affecting her grade (participation points).
2. Parent/guardian contact. Call the student's parent/guardian and voice your concerns. Ask the parent/guardian if they have suggestions for you, some insight you should be aware of regarding the student. Ask for their support as well.
3. Positive feedback ... use whatever works for the student ... positive calls/notes home. Positive verbal feedback when she is participating appropriately (e.g., "Thank you for your insightful contributions during our class discussion on Prohibition today. You really moved the conversation forward.").
Good luck!